What Octane is Your Freestyle Recovery?

Recovery Grades

When you fill up your tank at the gas station, usually you are offered three grades of gasoline, regular (low octane 87), mid range (medium octane 91), and premium (high octane 93). The high-octane gas is more expensive, but it increases the energy and efficiency of the engine. It makes your car go faster.

Low and Medium Octane

In swimming, I like to describe the freestyle recovery as having three octane grades; low, medium and high. The lowest octane recovery means that the elbow is bent almost maximally, the length of the arm reduced by half, as it recovers from the release phase after the propulsion and moves to the front of the body for the next stroke cycle. This form of recovery requires the least amount of energy for a given stroke cycle rate, and not surprisingly, it is what we see in most distance freestyle swimmers.

When we get to shorter, middle-distanced races like the 100 and 200 meters, we often see the hand elevating from the water, with the elbow less bent on the recovery. This middle-octane form of recovery requires more work than the low-octane recovery, but produces more kinetic energy for the same stroke rate.

High Octane

Finally, in the sprint freestyle event, the 50 meter, we often see the hand elevated even further, or even a complete straight-armed recovery, the high-octane recovery. With the arm straightened, the radius of the arm has now doubled from the low-octane recovery stroke. If the stroke rate is the same as with the low-octane recovery, the kinetic energy in this motion is quadrupled. In fact, we often see the stroke rate in the 50 sprinter at around twice the rate of the distance swimmer, which means that the kinetic energy is quadrupled again. While doing both, the energy in the recovering arm of a straight-armed sprinter could be 16 times greater than the recovering arm of a slower, bent-armed distance swimmer. That requires a lot more work of the sprinter to create all of that energy. So why do it?

Coupling Motions

Once the stroke rate gets above 80 or so, the recovering arm becomes one of the two coupling motions of the freestyler. The other is the rotating body. The degree of coupling, augmenting the force of the underwater pulling arm, or the kick, is proportional to the energy in the coupling motion. In other words, the more energy in the recovering arm and/or the rotating body, the further down the pool we swim with each pull, so long as the two motions are connected.

Just like in the car, the faster we want to swim, the more octane we need in the recovering motion. Sprinters need high octane in order to win, while distance swimmers often like to use low to medium octane recoveries, saving their energy for the body rotation and the underwater pull and kick.

It makes no sense to use a high-octane recovery, requiring a lot of effort, if the stroke rate is around 60 or slower, a hip-driven freestyle. The reason is that the pulling arm is held out front during most of the recovering motion and by the time it starts its propulsion, the recovering arm is already in the water and lost its kinetic energy. In other words, there is no coupling going on with the pull with this slow of a stroke rate. The motions are not connected.

Because of the sheer mass of the upper body, the rotation of the body is the most important coupling motion we have in freestyle. Therefore, regardless of the level of octane used in the recovery motion, one should always use a fast body rotation with the pulling arm in propulsive phase.

Rotation is Key

In teaching these various forms of freestyle technique at The Race Club, we often imagine that there is a string going from the shoulders straight up to the sky. With each stroke, we try to get the swimmers to bring the elbow up to the string. In this way, regardless of whether the recovering motion is low, medium or high octane, with the elbow at the string, the body (or at least the shoulders) must be rotated fully. That means that the body must turn quickly to the other side in order for the other elbow to reach the string. The quickness of the body rotation creates a lot of coupling energy for the underwater pull. One can then add the recovering arm’s energy to the body rotation, low for distance, medium for mid distance or high for sprints, to optimize the technique for each race.

No one leaves The Race Club without having at least two freestyle techniques, because there is no one technique that works well for all distances. Some, like Race Club swimmer and Olympic champion Nathan Adrian, change their technique during the race. Nathan often goes from a mid-octane freestyle recovery to a high-octane, straight-armed recovery with a higher stroke rate to finish his 100-meter freestyle. Nathan wins a lot of races that way.

If you need to tune up your engine, come to The Race Club and let us help you determine what grade of arm recovery you need in your freestyle events.

Yours in swimming,

Gary Sr.

10 Responses to What Octane is Your Freestyle Recovery?

  1. Dan

    Well, octane is only somewhat related to energy per unit weight. Octane’s main importance is ability to resist detonation or preignition in engines. Detonation occurs when an engine piston is compressing the air and fuel mixture, and the mixtures ignites before the spark plug fires. This causes a uncontrolled explosion in the cylinder which is like hitting a hammer on top of the piston. Too much detonation can burn a hole right through the piston. The higher the octane, the less likely the fuel is to detonate.

    The higher the octane, the higher the engine builder can design the compression on the engine. The higher the compression, the more power you can make. So higher octane is related to more power because the you design a higher performance engine.

    But, putting high octane fuel in an engine designed for low compression results in almost zero power gain. Don’t waste your money on high octane gas if your engine is designed to run on low octane fuel.

     
    • garyhallsr

      Dan,

      Thanks for the lesson on octane. It is not meant to be an exact comparison, but rather an analogy which actually works pretty well. Sprinters are built with high compression engines while distance swimmers are not. We recommend high octane freestyle for sprints but not for distance events (200 and up). Although it is worth mentioning that some distance swimmers, such as Janet Evans and Leah Smith, use high octane recovery on their distance events…but with shoulder driven (high stroke rate) technique.

       
  2. Lee

    Gary,
    Please comment about the kayak stroke. Is this the same as your shoulder driven freestyle?

    I understand the motion of the arm is like throwing an object and typically the elbow is not high.

    I understand most sprinters are using kayak. Is that correct?

     
    • garyhallsr

      I am not a kayaker but it seems that all kayakers use a relatively fast stroke rate when racing. Shoulder driven vs Hip driven is related to the time the hand is held out front, which is stroke rate. All elite sprinters use shoulder driven freestyle technique with SR of 120 or higher.

       
  3. Jim Plank

    And conversely don’t put low octane gas into a high octane engine. Mistimed ignition, low power, and premature engine wear are the consequences. If your Mercedes calls for 91 octane you better stick to it. But although the analogy is not perfect we know what Gary is relating to us in this enjoyable to read article.

     
  4. Ana

    Hi, in which age group do you teach the three freestyle tecnique?

     
    • Mary Hall

      HI Ana, We teach the 3 styles of freestyle to all of our swimmers of ages 7 and up and of all abilities. Most swimmers only utilize 2 of the styles most of the time, but it is good to know all 3. We also help them discover which freestyle to use when. Thanks!

       
  5. Gary of Michigan

    What about “gallop” timing? Many Olympians use what’s called gallop timing in freestyle.

     
    • Gary Hall Sr

      One of the key components of using the gallop or hybrid freestyle is having a strong kick. It is an excellent technique for the 100 and up when performed well with a strong surge kick. We see it most commonly used with lower octane recovery.

       

Add a Comment