More on the Late Breath Butterfly

Why the Late Breath Butterfly Makes Sense (Continued)…

The first article I wrote on the late breath butterfly, as used by Olympic Champion Joseph Schooling, pertained to the advantage of increasing coupling energy as the head snaps down timed with the second down kick. There is more to this story, however, as the late breath butterfly may also reduce frontal drag.

The fastest way to swim butterfly is without breathing. Few would argue against that. However, the concept of going fast without oxygen works only in the 50 meter sprints. Beyond that, we depend on at least 50% of our energy coming from the aerobic system, so in the 100 or longer events, we must learn to breathe often.

Breathing is problematic in that the elevation of the head, whether to the side or front, will increase frontal drag and slow the swimmer down. The higher the elevation of the head and shoulders, the more vertical the body becomes and the greater the frontal drag. Unlike breaststroke, where the body comes to nearly a screeching halt when the shoulders are elevated and the thighs brought forward, in butterfly, the speed never goes to near zero. Therefore, maintaining a relatively horizontal body position is more important in butterfly than in breaststroke.

Every Detail Counts

I refer to swimming as the sport of millimeters, tenths of seconds and degrees. In other words, the little details matter. Using the late breath butterfly technique is yet another example of that. The difference with this technique is that rather than lifting the head up early in the pulling cycle, the swimmer keeps the head down up to a tenth of a second longer. The head is lifted for the breath when the hands are further back in the pulling cycle. With the late breath the head is kept in the tucked down position as long as possible, rather than lifting it early and holding it up longer. Once it is elevated, it is then brought back down quickly, timed with the hand entry to maximize the coupling energy with the down kick. The head is held out of the water for less time.

By keeping the head down just a tenth of second or so longer, the swimmer maintains a lower drag position for that much more time, resulting in less deceleration. Less deceleration means the swimmer’s speed doesn’t slow as much and less work is required to get the speed back up on the next down kick.

In the 1924 Olympic Games, Johnny Weissmuller won the 100 m freestyle swimming with his head out of the water in a time of 57 seconds. Ironically, his rationale for doing so was to reduce frontal drag. He did not realize he was increasing frontal drag with his head out of the water, but he was so talented, he won anyway.

Function Over Form

The physics of frontal drag have not changed since then. It looks beautiful and graceful to see a butterflyer extending the head up and out of the water, holding that position while gliding forward. If we had the dolphin’s tail and could propel ourselves up and over the water, then having the head out would be a great idea, but we don’t have that much strength. Too much of the body remains under water during the breath, causing tremendous frontal drag.

One of the reasons coaches don’t like the late breath is that it looks weird. It is not as graceful looking as the early breathers. We also associate this technique with six year old swimmers, trying to learn to do butterfly for the first time. Since most of them don’t have the strength yet to get their arms around quickly, they take a short pause at the end of their pull, with the hands at their sides. Then they lift the head for the breath and recover their arms over the water. It is easier for them to do the butterfly stroke without breathing during the pulling phase. When older swimmers use this technique, there is guilt by association.

Experimenting

The late breath technique can be done with the same high stroke rate as the early breath, but like every other technique, it must be practiced. At The Race Club, we fully understand that one technique does not work equally well for all swimmers. We keep an open mind about which technique may be the best for each swimmer.

Later this summer, I look forward to testing and comparing the frontal drag forces and propulsion forces with the early versus late breath techniques in butterfly using our new drag/propulsion technology and will report back on our findings. In the meantime, don’t be afraid to try the late breath butterfly technique. After all, the six year olds may have it right.

Yours in swimming,

Gary Sr.

8 Responses to More on the Late Breath Butterfly

  1. Robert Torkelund

    I totally agree on the head down before the arms go in, in Butterfry – as a part time coach I have noticed that the later the head goes in and the higher it is held, the more the body starts to lose balance at the back and the swimmer starts to “stand” upright in the water . . . . with the head up, the feet sink and slowly it gets worse because the swimmer has to use more and more energy to keep up and he/she gets tired faster . . .

     
    • Gary Hall Sr.

      One of the important keys to fly is to elevate more with the neck and less with the shoulders in order to avoid getting too vertical. Of course, the legs must stay strong throughout the entire fly race in order to maintain a better body position and keep the propulsion.

       
  2. Texas Flyer

    Looking forward to some videos of this.

     
    • Gary Hall Sr.

      Not many elite flyers are using this technique, though we may see more of it in the future.

       
  3. Eugene

    Great thoughts as usual Gary! Love the Race Club articles as they make you think, not just provide a magic recipe for success. Got one question though.

    As far as I understood the concepts of this technique, the swimmer has less time to inhale the air since his head is elevated for a shorter period of time in late breath fly. Usually when flyer gets tired during the swim he or she tends to prolongate the inhalation – probably because of respiratory muscles’ fatigue among others. And here there’s no room for a longer breath or even a standard one. Won’t this “overcompensate” the positive effect of reducing drag and lead to worse performance in the end?

     
    • Gary Hall Sr.

      It is a good question. If you compare the late breath technique to the quick, low profile breath of the 100 freestyler breathing every cycle, there is not a lot of time in either case. However, a swimmer is just exchanging some oxygen in for some CO2 out. If a swimmer needs a long, gasping breath, then he or she is not fit enough to be swimming the event. I am a great believer in breathing every cycle in fly, particularly for men, when done with a lower profile.

       
  4. Eugene

    Also, speaking about the drag in fly, especially during the breath, I’m struggling to fix one thing. When I do the second kick my legs are kicking down instead of pushing the water backwards, even while not having a breath. Not only it leads to a more vertical body position but also reduces propulsion creating only some lift instead (which is probably good but not what we need at the first place). I generate quite a lot of power which allows me to swim a 50 meter fly in 25-something seconds but it feels like my limit unless I fix this deep downkick issue. Could you recommend some drills that are supposed to fix the dropping of the legs on a second kick? “Just don’t kick down” mantra doesn’t work for me unfortunately… Thanks!

     
    • Gary Hall Sr.

      On your stomach, the down kick is considerably more propulsive than the up kick. Most great butterflyers are taking two strong down kicks (though Lazlo Cseh takes only one). The up kick is also important, as is the speed and degree which the knees bend for the down kick. Getting past 60 degrees of knee bend seems to be a threshold point for frontal drag. The more plantar flexibility one has in the ankle, the less the knees need to bend to create propulsion. If I were you, I would work on plantar flexibility and the up kick.

       

Add a Comment